In this gripping comparison of fearful avoidant vs dismissive avoidant, we uncover the hidden motives.
The maze of attachment styles can feel overwhelming, especially when it comes to understanding the subtle yet powerful differences between fearful avoidant vs dismissive avoidant. Whether you’re reflecting on your own experiences or trying to make sense of someone else’s, you’re in the right place.
Fearful Avoidant vs Dismissive Avoidant
When it comes to understanding avoidant attachment styles, you’ll encounter two primary subtypes: fearful avoidant and dismissive avoidant. While both share a tendency to avoid emotional closeness, the ways they express this avoidance are distinctly different.
By understanding the key traits of each, you can navigate your relationships with greater clarity, reducing frustration and uncertainty.
Fearful Avoidant Attachment: The Push-Pull Dilemma
If you have a fearful avoidant attachment, your relationships often feel like a balancing act between two conflicting forces: the deep desire for connection and the equally powerful fear of getting hurt.
You constantly seek intimacy, yet, as soon as it’s within reach, fear takes over and makes you pull away.
Key Characteristics:
1. Craving closeness, Fearing rejection
You may constantly want emotional connection, but your past experiences or fears of abandonment lead you to sabotage intimacy.
For example, after a few days of feeling deeply connected to a friend or partner, you might start distancing yourself without understanding why.
2. Inconsistent Behaviors
One minute, you’re all-in, ready to commit and share everything, and the next, you’re putting up walls. It creates confusion not just for you, but for the people in your life.
For example, you might plan a romantic weekend getaway, but then cancel it last minute because the thought of being too vulnerable terrifies you.
3. Fear of Vulnerability
You often avoid fully opening up, fearing the vulnerability might be used against you later. Even though you desire close, deep relationships, you hold back, keeping your guard up.
4. Emotional Experience
Constantly torn between needing closeness and fearing rejection, you often feel like you’re living in emotional turmoil. You might experience high levels of anxiety, especially when things get too intimate or emotional.
It’s common to feel both drawn to and overwhelmed by relationships, which can lead to sudden withdrawal or avoidance.
Example: Imagine being in a relationship where, after sharing an intimate moment, you suddenly feel an intense urge to pull away, worried that being too close might lead to rejection. You might not text your partner for days, leaving them confused and uncertain. This push-pull dynamic can strain even the healthiest relationships.
Dismissive Avoidant Attachment: The Emotional Fortress
If you’re dismissive avoidant, your approach to relationships is simple: emotional closeness isn’t a priority. You might engage in surface-level interactions, but when it comes to deep emotional bonds, you keep your distance.
Independence is your priority, and you rarely rely on others for emotional support.
Key Characteristics:
1. Need for independence
You value your autonomy above all else. Emotional dependence on others feels like a threat to your self-sufficiency.
Dr. Sue Johnson, author of Hold Me Tight, explains, “Dismissive avoidants see emotional reliance as weakness.” For you, asking for help or opening up feels unnecessary and uncomfortable.
2. Emotional distance
Even in close relationships, you maintain emotional detachment. For example, while your partner may want to discuss feelings, you prefer to talk about practical or non-emotional subjects.
When conflict arises, instead of resolving it, you might retreat, shutting down emotionally or physically distancing yourself.
3. Downplaying Emotions
You tend to deny the importance of emotional needs. You might tell yourself, “I don’t need anyone” or “Feelings just complicate things.” This mindset creates a barrier to forming deep, meaningful connections.
4. Emotional Experience
Unlike fearful avoidants, you don’t experience high levels of anxiety. Instead, you feel more comfortable keeping relationships at arm’s length.
Emotional vulnerability isn’t something you seek, and in fact, you suppress feelings to maintain your independence.
Example: You could be in a long-term relationship but avoid discussing deep emotional issues. If your partner tries to bring up a concern or talk about their feelings, you might respond with indifference or change the subject, making it difficult for them to feel emotionally connected to you.
Fearful Avoidant vs Dismissive Avoidant: Key Differences
1. Desire for Closeness
Fearful avoidants crave intimacy but fear rejection. They often engage in emotional push-pull behaviors. On the other hand, dismissive avoidants prefer independence and avoid deep emotional closeness altogether.
2. Response to Intimacy
Fearful avoidants exhibit inconsistent behaviors, swinging between wanting closeness and retreating from it. They want connection but are terrified of vulnerability.
Dismissive avoidants are more consistent in their avoidance—they don’t want emotional intimacy in the first place.
3. Emotional Conflict
Fearful avoidants experience high anxiety around relationships, leading to internal conflict between their desires and fears. In contrast, dismissive avoidants experience less anxiety but remain emotionally detached and distant.
How This Plays Out in Real Life
– Fearful Avoidant: Imagine starting a new friendship. You might feel excited to connect deeply, but soon after, you start doubting whether this person truly likes you or if they’ll eventually hurt you.
You might send mixed signals, one moment inviting them to spend time together, and the next, avoiding their calls.
– Dismissive Avoidant: In a relationship, you might be the person who avoids discussing feelings or avoids any situation where emotions are involved.
Your partner might feel like they’re never truly connecting with you, even though you’re present in the relationship. You view emotional needs as something unnecessary, pushing away any attempts at vulnerability.
Understanding the depths of fearful avoidant vs dismissive avoidant attachment style helps you identify areas for personal growth. With this clarity, you won’t feel the need to seek more answers elsewhere!
This article contains Amazon affiliate links.
